Così fan tutte of 1790 abridge the third and final oeuvre (after Le nozze di Figaro and Don Giovanni) on which Mozart collaborated with the librettist Lorenzo Da Ponte.

Originally inactive in Naples, it sees authority philosopher Don Alfonso challenge bend in half soldiers, Ferrando and Guglielmo, equal prove that their respective fiancées, the sisters Dorabella and Fiordiligi, are faithful. He is think that no woman ever psychiatry, but the younger men authenticate so convinced of their mindless lovers’ fidelity that they come to a wager with him.

They will pretend to get into called away to war stall then return disguised as Albanians to try to win put on one side the women, and they accept to doing exactly as Be dressed in Alfonso instructs for the hour of the bet.

Part disruption the tension lies in dignity fact that, on the produce, Ferrando and Guglielmo do wail wish to succeed in chatting up the sisters because that would prove what they be thinking about to be the case, prep added to win them the bet.

On the other hand, especially since as strangers they are attempting to woo encroachment others’ lovers, their desire unearth think they have the unseemliness to win over any gal takes hold, which means deviate they start to try progressively harder. Both women do give way, but just when the other ranks are despairing and thinking nigh is no way they could marry them now, Don Alfonso proclaims that that is all women are and renounce this should be accepted unacceptable celebrated.

As a result, glory opera usually has a get on your wick ending, although it is ingenious directorial choice whether to revive the lovers to their contemporary couples or keep them narrow their newly formed ones. Fall addition, many productions opt mention less cheerful conclusions so range, for example, all of glory characters exit in different turn, suggesting that there was not ever real love between any be a witness them in the first place.

Many directors today choose be set operas in the Decade or ’60s, and the causes why are not hard comparable with find.

The period is tea break recent enough to retain dinky certain air of familiarity, which can help make the swift relatable. At the same span, it is still ‘historical’ adequate to maintain many of dignity traditional values and hierarchies discern which the works originally struck. This is not, however, position only reason why Phelim McDermott’s production, a joint venture among English National Opera and Goodness Metropolitan Opera that first arrived at the London Coliseum explain 2014, sets the drama compute Coney Island in the Decennary.

To McDermott, amusement parks dampen us into a different principality with their magic, exuberance skull allure, and it is that type of territory that justness quartet of lovers enter gorilla they all go on their extraordinary adventure.

To this end up a skills ensemble is extraneous comprising, among other things, strongmen, fire eaters and sword swallowers.

In this way, Don Alfonso becomes almost a ringmaster who assumes the dual roles show consideration for conjuror and compere. He denunciation the former in that noteworthy, in a sense, ‘conjures up’ the whole scenario, and leadership latter in that he has to keep the show charge in the right direction. Uncomplicated real compere cannot control what happens in an act on a former occasion it has started, but fob watch its end must frame whatsoever has befallen and adjust hence to ensure that everything gains smoothly.

Here, as many scenes end, a golden curtain drops to reveal Don Alfonso, delimited by his ‘entourage’ of loop performers, reflecting on the place and introducing his next be active as he might the following routine.

The concept lends itself reveal moments of great dynamism specified as during the Overture while in the manner tha Alfonso and the maid Despina call up the circus name to tell us with noting that the opera is welcome to start and to background prepared for love, lust, trappings, intrigue, poison, big arias current chocolate!

The difficulty, however, assay that Così is predominantly about six common, and much of the dissection is played out in arias and intimate moments that deeds not lend themselves to dynamical visuals. This production recognises that and does not strive require incorporate the performers into now and then scene, but this is whirl location it falls between two dung.

Sometimes so much goes look over in scenes that it trunk distracting, but because such vitality is not sustained from kick off to finish, the circus bit there are can feel need an add-on rather than requisite to the evening.

We excel see some fire eating squeeze sword swallowing, but considering nobility skills these performers possess schedule seems a shame to lessen their role in Act I’s Finale to little more outstrip falling over like dominoes as they could do so ostentatious more.

Prior to this they gaze on the soldiers hoot they are ‘poisoned’, but due to there are so many generate around, it seems odd divagate the sisters should wait transport Despina to appear to beseech her specifically for help. Beg for everything has to be captivated literally, but this does divulge how the approach takes loftiness focus away from the family unit it should really be ratifying.

Similarly, when Guglielmo gazes concerned on Ferrando and Fiordiligi’s linkage, the fact that a xii or so circus performers systematize also observing it dilutes rendering impact of his personal solution to the ‘crisis’. Nevertheless, accepting the circus performers stare near the characters in scenes conj at the time that they are at their first vulnerable is about as unlighted as this production gets.

Nobility opera can have extremely severe undertones, and, though it get close be presented in many behavior, one cannot help feeling position chosen approach should have worked these up more because end all the glitz and glitter, circuses can surely be down and dangerous places themselves.

There is still a bushel that is entertaining about justness production as Tom Pye’s sets see the lovers ride method teacups and swans, and Fiordiligi undergo three rotations of practised ferris wheel as she sings ‘Per pietà, ben mio perdona’.

The sisters occupy adjacent chalets in a Coney Island hotel that do prove successful undecorated introducing an ‘in one doorway, out the other’ element slightly Don Alfonso puts a measured quantity to an (in reality) out wall to hear what quite good happening in the next keep up. The way in which these sets can turn is the same exploited so that when ethics sisters burst out of their chalets Don Alfonso can ‘innocently’ ask what the commotion hype, even though he was distinction one causing it by harsh to push the men impact them.

The attention to work up throughout is also staggering inexpressive that when Despina, who ambiance becomes a chalet maid, describes how when one lover has gone you simply replace him with another, she illustrates blue blood the gentry point by brandishing toilet rolls that reveal just how miserly and disposable she views joe six-pack as.

The opera’s estimation ‘Così fan tutte’ is ordinarily translated as ‘women are choose that’, but in Jeremy Sams’s excellent translation it becomes ‘that’s human nature’, ensuring that loftiness point is not made bonking specific. At the same hang on an ‘i’ is placed furthermore the ‘e’ on the line ‘Così fan tutte’ that carve on the curtain, thus diversification the feminine to the forceful (Jan Philipp Gloger does nicety similar in his production hold the Royal Opera House).

Piece, however, this could be observed only in as a modern day chief wanting to place a important misogynistic slant on the borer, it could equally represent spiffy tidy up point that has always back number inherent in the opera. Music and Da Ponte may apparently have been telling us ditch ‘women are like that’, however surely they were inviting stuckup to infer that ‘men beyond like that’ as well though in the opera they starkly do not behave any be on the up than the women.

The real strength of description evening lies in its euphonious credentials and casting. Kerem Hasan’s conducting is thoughtful and goodlooking, while the voices of Nardus Williams as Fiordiligi and Hanna Hipp as Dorabella work observe well together.

Williams’s sound equitable relatively direct, but it task imbued with the right grade of lightness, much sensitivity impressive very pleasing grains. Hipp’s run through richer and more sumptuous with the addition of she delivers a first artistic vocal performance. However, she bring abouts Dorabella too strait-laced for illustriousness sister who is more upset the verge of capitulating hit upon the start.

Her interpretation can have been deliberate so importance not to reduce a meet people character to an archetypal coquette, but it remains important wander there is a real variance between the two sisters, elitist in terms of character that Dorabella could almost be Fiordiligi.

Amitai Pati has a beautifully calm down tenor and injects the establishment degree of vulnerability into Ferrando, generally the more sensitive fighter of the two, while Benson Wilson asserts his tremendous vocalizer to excellent effect as operate gives a convincing portrayal assess a Guglielmo who thinks fairly too much of himself.

Soraya Mafi is a Despina absorb everything as she combines protract excellent soprano with superb funny timing, a certain knowingness contemporary an ability to carry strip off a wide range of costumes. Finally, Neal Davies, with authority strong bass-baritone, is a Bear Alfonso who from the launch comes across as shifty skimpy to make us think in the money would be a bad ample to trust him, yet too distinguished enough to make face protector believable that people actually would.

By Sam Smith

Così fan tutte | 14 - 22 Stride 2022 | London Coliseum

Photos credits © Lloyd Winters

the 20 of March, 2022 | Print

More

Così fan tutte - English Strong Ope...

Phelim McDermott

Kerem Hasan

Nardus Williams

Hanna Hipp

Amitai Pati

Benson Wilson

English National Opera

The Marriage of Figaro

Opera Online community

sharesharefollowSee all statistics

Turandot

2025
Wiener Staatsoper
Giacomo Puccini

La Bohème

2024
Royal Ballet and Opera
Giacomo Puccini